Contact Castaways on the Lake in Webster, NY at
585-323-2943
Boat Docking Available At The Sandbar Park.
Castaways On The Lake
244 Lake Road
Webster, NY 14580
Contact Castaways on the Lake in Webster, NY at
FAQs
Castaways on the Lake offers lakeside dining with spectacular views and gorgeous sunsets over Lake Ontario, plus cozy tiered decks suitable for spring and summer outdoor enjoyment.
It’s at 244 Lake Road, Webster, NY 14580, with convenient free parking and boat docking available at nearby Sandbar Park.
The menu features a range of pasta, seafood, fish, chicken, steak (including Cajun-rubbed blackened prime rib), plus appetizers like crab cakes, coconut shrimp, and more.
Yes-off‑premises catering and take‑out are available. They cater events like weddings, corporate luncheons, anniversaries, and more. Pickup and delivery options are offered.
Lunch includes favorites like crab cake sandwich, lobster roll, fried grouper sandwich, jambalaya, and the shore platter. Dinner options include steaks, seafood platters, plus Key Lime pie and other desserts.
It has been a favorite lakeside dining destination since opening in 1906.
Yes, boat docking is available at the Sandbar Park for those arriving by water.
Our lunch menu includes locally inspired favorites like Crab Cake Sandwich, New England Lobster Roll, Grouper Sandwich (blackened or fried), Baja Fish Tacos, seafood-stuffed mushrooms, clam strips, and more. Each entrée comes with your choice of fries, coleslaw, macaroni salad, or house chips.
Absolutely! With over 30 years of catering experience, we can plan and cater weddings, receptions, showers, corporate luncheons, retirements, birthdays, and more—whether at our location or yours. We offer both pickup and delivery for your convenience.
You can relax on our two-tiered lakeside decks in spring and summer. We also offer outdoor dining under a heated patio deck so you can enjoy the views comfortably even when it's cooler.
Yes-apart from our hearty seafood and steak dishes, we also offer salads (like grilled or blackened chicken, grilled salmon, coconut shrimp) and light appetizers such as bruschetta, steamed mussels, artichoke French, and more.
Yes, kids 10 and under can choose from items like chicken fingers, chicken sandwich, hamburger, fish fry, clam strips, fried shrimp, or pasta with butter and cheese-all served with fries or applesauce.
We serve several desserts including our signature Key Lime pie, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cheesecake, Peanut Butter Pie, Ultimate Chocolate Cake, and more. Whole pies (like the Key Lime) are available to go with a 24-hour notice.
Yes-you can dock your boat at Sandbar Park and walk over to the restaurant—it's that convenient for those arriving by water.
We offer plenty of free parking and comfortably spaced seating, making us an ideal lakeside dining spot whether by land or water.
